Supreme Court Justice Ellen France

FRANCE, Ellen Dolour 

 Supreme Court Justice Ellen Dolour France

 

Professional Data:

2013 Judge Survey Score (1-10): 7.7     Ranking (out of 63):  26thJustice Court of Appeal President Ellen France

Postion & Titles:  Former deputy Solicitor General, Dame
Judge of: Supreme Court, since July 2016 Previously, President of the Court of Appeal since 2014

Court of Appeal since 2006.

High Court Auckland, 2004

Specializations and Professional Interests: Politics, Government, Public policy.  Demonstrates glaring deficiency in many areas of law, notably commercial law.
Professional Comments: More studious than judicially adept.  Sadly dishonest, which compromises the studious propensity on occasions where Crown or powerful interests are at stake.  At the Supreme Court this means most of the time.

Owes her appointment and advancement to being a bureaucratic functionary who kept her head low and frequently said ‘yes’ to political powers.  Bench performance in High Court was analogous to a fish out of water.  Was often intimidated into making poor decisions and losing control of proceedings.  Rapidly kicked upstairs to the Court of Appeal where, in contrast to the High Court, regularly sitting next to two experienced judges brought some maturity and confidence.  In France’s case her malleability was an asset to promotion.

Justice France is perhaps the best example of an egocentric court hierarchy promoting a weak and malleable political hack who is unlikely to pose a threat to her strong-willed colleagues whims.  Her often rash willingness to act dishonestly without much prompting to protect parochial interests has made her a much relied upon but not particularly respected judicial colleague.

In a country where the judicial appointment process is routinely opaque, Ms France’s rise still mystifies many.

Background / Education: Has an LLB (Hons) from Auckland University and an LLM from Queen’s University, Ontario.

Before being appointed to the High Court in April 2002 Ellen France was a senior legal adviser in the Department of Justice Law Reform Division; Crown Counsel and then Deputy Solicitor-General in the Crown Law Office.  She was appointed to the Court of Appeal in June 2006.  Deeply involved in the bureaucracy of politics.

Degrees: LLB (Hons) Auckland,
LLM, Queen’s University, Ontario
Admitted to the Bar: 1983
Company Involvements:  none found

Personal Data

Born: 1956
New Zealand
Sex: Female
Married: Simon Peter France Children:
Interesting Relationships and Coincidences: Husband Simon Peter France is a judge in the Wellington High court.
Miscellaneous: Personally mild-mannered, with that ‘deer in headlights’ look about her when she is legally out of her depth or in the presence of alpha personality types.  Justice Ellen France owes her success in large part to her willingness to go with the flow and keep her head down when it counts.

 

 

Q. Are you shocked by Justice Ellen France‘s ruling? A. Shocked isn’t the word for it. Maybe dumbfounded, certainly saddened. I expected much more from the
www.stiassny.org/9_questions.html – 66k – CachedSimilar pages

The Judges of the Court of Appeal | Courts of New Zealand

The Honourable Justice O’Regan The Honourable Justice Robertson The Honourable Justice Arnold The Honourable Justice Ellen France
www.courtsofnz.govt.nz/about/appeal/judges.html – 22k – CachedSimilar pages

[PDF]

WEDNESDAY 2 AUGUST 2006

File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat – View as HTML
THE HON JUSTICE ELLEN FRANCE ? in chambers 9:00am. 1/06. Dale Anthony Broome (R A A Weir). v. The Queen (M Woolford). The Ministry has taken all reasonable
www.courtsofnz.govt.nz/business/calendar/documents/CourtofAppealListfor2August2006.PDF – Similar pages

Court of Appeal of New Zealand – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

On 18 May 2006, Justice Ellen France of the High Court was raised to the Court of Appeal. On 19 December 2006, William M. Wilson QC was appointed to the
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Court_of_Appeal_of_New_Zealand – 28k – CachedSimilar pages

Legislation Advisory Committee: Guidelines on Process & Content of

Mr Richard Clarke, Chairperson Mr J G Fogarty, QC Ms Ellen France, Deputy Solicitor-General Ms Janet McLean Professor Matthew S R Palmer The Hon Justice
www.justice.govt.nz/lac/pubs/2001/legislative_guide_2000/members.html – 10k – CachedSimilar pages

Mooting team success – Faculty of Law – The University of Auckland

Waikato (May 9): Bell Gully partner Ian Gault joined Justice Heath and JusticeEllen France to sit as judges for the Waikato final in which Rebecca Rose and
www.law.auckland.ac.nz/uoa/law/news/2006/05/more_stout_mooting.cfm – 14k – CachedSimilar pages

Past Visitors

Justice Ellen France. 3 October – 25 November 2005. High Court Wellington. Professor George Williams. 25 July – 3 September and 14 November – 23 December
cccs.law.unimelb.edu.au/go/people/visitors/past-visitors/index.cfm – 37k – CachedSimilar pages

[DOC]

October 2003 Inside this Issue 1 Report on September Judges

File Format: Microsoft Word – View as HTML
Justice Ellen France alerted members to provisions in the Judicial Matters Bill that provide for part-time members of the judiciary.
www.wwla.org.nz/abode/19/documents/newsletter%20October%202003.doc – Similar pages

Police and Justice hotly refutes Le Pen’s comments on Swiss

Police and Justice hotly refutes Le Pen’s comments on Swiss immigration. April 5, 2007 – 08:49 Bern, Switzerland :: posted by Ellen Wallace
www.genevalunch.com/node/3452 – 23k – CachedSimilar pages

Faculty Page

Study Abroad. Photo Album · Tours, FranceEllen R. Justice-Templeton Ph.D. Chairwoman and Professor of French, 1972
www.hillsdale.edu/…/hcdept/french1.jpg&hlink=french&dlink=french&dept=31 – 9k – CachedSimilar pages